Honey Peanut Butter

16 oz jar

Retail Price: $6.79

Our Price: $4.95 (Save 27%)

16 oz jar

Why You’ll Love It

I don’t know kung fu and I’ve never learned to play the piano, but what I do know is how to make honey peanut butter really, really well. Some people might consider my single-minded obsession with nut butters to be a waste of time, but I disagree. Can you kung fu a piece a celery into tasting better? I think not.
SKU: 855188003035

About This Brand

The Justin’s Nut Butter brand does everything they can to bring their customers the best-tasting nut butters around. Their products range from Justin’s Classic Peanut Butter to more adventurous (and insanely delicious) offerings like Justin’s Mini Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups, leaving out mystery additives and excess sugars. Whether used in favorite recipes, spread on a slice of freshly baked bread, or eaten straight from the jar, it’s easy to love the lineup that Justin’s Nut Butter has to offer. The story behind Justin’s Nut Butter Justin’s Nut Butter started with a man named Justin and one truly powerful idea. Combined with his immense ambition and a simple food processor, he took his affinity for local and natural ingredients to make something he could share with his community. Justin was inspired to make nut butters due to his vegetarian diet and active lifestyle. Nut butter was a staple in his diet (it’s an amazing source of protein), but the products he was able...
Shop The Brand


Dry Roasted Peanuts, Honey Powder (Sugar, Honey), Palm Fruit Oil, Sea Salt.

California residents: Learn more on Prop 65 warning. Disclaimer: Information, statements, and reviews regarding products have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. Results vary person to person, and there is no guarantee of specific results. Thrive Market assumes no liability for inaccuracies or misstatements about products.
Serving Size 2 tbsp (32g) Servings Per Container 14

Amount Per Serving

Calories 190 Calories from Fat 140

% Daily Value*
Total Fat 16g 25%
Saturated Fat 3g 15%
Trans Fat 0g
Cholesterol 0mg 0%
Sodium 65mg 3%
Total Carbohydrate 8g 3%
Dietary Fiber 2g 8%
Sugars 4g
Protein 7g

Vitamin A 0%
Vitamin C 0%
Calcium 2%
Iron 2%

Contains peanuts. Contains trace amounts of tree nuts and soy due to processing on shared equipment.

Reviews For Honey Peanut Butter

Based on 17 Reviews


Justin's has me sold 100% my favorite!

- Erica Jones

Money wastage purchase!

I bought Justin's Honey Peanut Butter with excitement, from my neighborhood grocery store. I am for all things non-GMO, even though I am on a shoe-string budget.

Huge disappointment! I concur with plenty of reviews herein: too gritty; no taste of honey; hard to spread on bread, even toast! I buy peanut butter for my child, and he loves it smooth. I don't typically spend that much on peanut butter, but I thought buying "with Honey", would save me from buying jelly (as well). What a money wastage purchase! Not again!

- Doreen Lwanga

Where's the Honey

First off I have to say I ordered it along with my free introductory gift so I was pleased with the package as a whole: Six bucks for a jar of PB and a jar of coconut oil... Including shipping. I didn't care for the Justin's peanut butter. It contains palm oil which is not an environmentally friendly product. Also, I couldn't taste the honey. I added two heaping tablespoons and I then I could taste a hint of honey. I'll probably have to add some next time I use it. But I still think it was a generous welcome offer from thrive. If they had a lower price point for free shipping, I'd shop there quite often but for now I'll stick to my local whole foods market.

- Rob

The best peanut butter ever

I absolutely love this peanut butter, yum!

- Lisa Alteio


This is a tough one to write. Because of the hype, I wanted to love this peanutbutter. Sadly I didn't. The texture is gritty as if there is sugar in it. It didn't have the honey flavor I was looking for. Essentially it was gritty regular peanutbutter.


So good!

First try of Justin's Peanut Butter. A bit grainy, but very good! I am pleased and will order again. True peanut taste.

- Marla

We love this PB

We love the taste of this peanut butter! It's hard to spread on bread, but I just heat it in the microwave for 20 seconds or so and it's much easier.

- Jenny

A bit disappointing

I normally love Justin's items, but I found this spread disappointing. I really can't taste the honey, at all, and the consistency is also a bit too thick and course for my taste. I won't be getting this one again, but I do enjoy other Justin's products.

- Nancy

Husband's Favorite

My husband likes the sweeter more spreadable conventional peanut butters but I don't by them because of the unhealthy ingredients. I was so happy to find this Justin's PB for such a good price on Thrive. He loves it! I order 2 at a time.

- Sara


my new fav!

- Lisa

It's really dry

It's super dry and not very creamy but it's still very tasty

- Juan


This peanut butter is so fantastic and I do not feel nearly as guilty eating it ;) The honey gives it a sweet taste. Make sure you stir it up before you eat it!

- Jade

Something wrong here

This peanut butter has a good taste but is gritty. The label says it contains "honey powder" made up of sugar, honey. Perhaps it isn't properly blended? I sent the company a message asking them why it might be gritty. No response.

- Candace

Good stuff

The reviewer who has no idea what palm kernel oil is, is wrong. This product is 100% natural. Palm kernel oil is saturated. Not hydrogenated. And the beef people have with Palm oils is not WHAT they are, it's that we clear thousands of acres of natural rain forest to get them. So if you care about that, this is probably not something you would buy anyway. But as far as a "health" choice goes, it's a good one. And it's a good peanut taste, too.

- Pook

A peanut butter that actually tastes like peanuts

The title speaks for itself. The price tag isnt bad either.

- Kenneth

guilty pleasure

my favorite brand of peanut butter with a better cost
it is my guilty pleasure that has a wonderful
taste i look forward to buying more <3

- Erika

love it

wonderful product

- Raquel Coll

Featured on Thrive Market

See All Articles
Get Hooked on Thrive Market’s Sustainably Caught Canned Seafood

Get Hooked on Thrive Market’s Sustainably Caught Canned Seafood

At Thrive Market, we don’t think a pantry is sufficiently stocked unless you could easily throw together a delicious, well-balanced, and nutritious meal with what’s inside. It’s one of the reasons ...

Read More
The 5 Key Components of the Ultimate Cheese and Charcuterie Board

The 5 Key Components of the Ultimate Cheese and Charcuterie Board

There’s something so simple, so elegant, and so gourmet about a charcuterie and cheese board.

Read More
Olive Oil Chocolate Chip Cookies Recipe

Olive Oil Chocolate Chip Cookies Recipe

We're always looking for new ways to enjoy chocolate chip cookies. Is any dessert more universally satisfying? Past variations have included milk-and-cookie shots and this skillet cookie—but right...

Read More