Classic Peanut Butter

16 oz jar

Retail Price: $6.79

Our Price: $4.95 (Save 27%)

16 oz jar

Why You’ll Love It

Justin’s Classic Peanut Butter is a great example of what delicious peanut butter can really be and is made with dry roasted peanuts and a touch of palm fruit oil—that’s all. No unfamiliar ingredients lurking inside, just pure peanut butter goodness that you can use for a PB&J, put in a banana smoothie, eat with an apple, and more.
SKU: 855188003004

About This Brand

The Justin’s Nut Butter brand does everything they can to bring their customers the best-tasting nut butters around. Their products range from Justin’s Classic Peanut Butter to more adventurous (and insanely delicious) offerings like Justin’s Mini Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups, leaving out mystery additives and excess sugars. Whether used in favorite recipes, spread on a slice of freshly baked bread, or eaten straight from the jar, it’s easy to love the lineup that Justin’s Nut Butter has to offer. The story behind Justin’s Nut Butter Justin’s Nut Butter started with a man named Justin and one truly powerful idea. Combined with his immense ambition and a simple food processor, he took his affinity for local and natural ingredients to make something he could share with his community. Justin was inspired to make nut butters due to his vegetarian diet and active lifestyle. Nut butter was a staple in his diet (it’s an amazing source of protein), but the products he was able...
Shop The Brand


Dry Roasted Peanuts, Palm Fruit Oil.

California residents: Learn more on Prop 65 warning. Disclaimer: Information, statements, and reviews regarding products have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. Results vary person to person, and there is no guarantee of specific results. Thrive Market assumes no liability for inaccuracies or misstatements about products.
Serving Size 2 tbsp (32g) Servings Per Container 14

Amount Per Serving

Calories 190 Calories from Fat 140

% Daily Value*
Total Fat 16g 25%
Saturated Fat 3g 15%
Trans Fat 0g
Cholesterol 0mg 0%
Sodium 35mg 2%
Total Carbohydrate 7g 2%
Dietary Fiber 4g 16%
Sugars 2g
Protein 8g

Vitamin A 0%
Vitamin C 0%
Calcium 2%
Iron 2%

Contains peanuts. Contains trace amounts of tree nuts and soy due to processing on shared equipment.

Reviews For Classic Peanut Butter

Based on 29 Reviews


The taste is great, similar to Trader Joe's version but it's completely solid. I have to melt it in the microwave before I can spread it.

- Niecie


Tastes great! A little runny but I don't mind as much

- Luis Rodriguez

Pretty good but...

Just one problem, oil separation. When I make peanut butter with my VitaMix blender, (a kinda messy job) the oil stays emulsified, doesn't separate ever. Why can't these folks find a way to do this??

- Raydene

Justins Peanut Butter

I purchase Justins for the first time. I thought it was delicious.

- Gary

Does Almond Butter Better

Creamy may be an optimistic description. I found this brand very runny even after thoroughly mixing. The almond butter in this line is delicious, so I had high hopes for the peanut butter.

- Deborah Smith

Real Plain

This product has a really blan flavor. The consistency is good, and it smells good.. does not taste good.

- M

Love it!

My favorite peanut butter by far! Super yummy and highly recommended. Great price on here also. I've seen it in my grocery store at about $12.99.

- Irene Rivera

Best peanut butter!

This is my favorite peanut butter! It's creamy and flavorful without all the extra added sugar. And you can't beat the price at Thrive.

- Loren


The taste is great but it is quite runnier than other natural peanut butter brands. The oil separates and is difficult to get it to mix together.

- Mrsmck07


This peanut butter has been my favorite for a couple of years now. The texture is creamy and fluid just as a natural peanut butter should be, and it's consistent grind makes it easy to adore.

- Amelia

It tastes like peanuts...

This peanut butter tastes the way that peanut butter should... like peanuts. No sweet sugary taste like other brands, just simple peanuts.

- Nathan

Peanut butter LOVE

My favorite peanut butter! Unable to find in my now, it's coming straight to my door! Good price too!

- Valerie


I eat this literally every day now with my Thrive coconut oil on toast. Perfect peanutty taste without the sugar and crap that's in regular peanut butter.

- Liz

Great PB!

We love Justins PB! It's a hit with the whole family. So much better then any other PB out there.

- Jamie

great peanut butter

Tastes great, and much healthier than the sugar-packed stuff you can buy at a supermarket. Not quite as creamy as store-bought, however.

- Alyssa

Justin's Classic Peanut Butter

It's very good, though it'd be tough to mess up peanut butter. We really love this-low sodium, especially compared to what's available at our store.

- Alison

Not bad

I wish there was a little salt to this product. I like peanut butter with a little salt. It's not bad though.

- Sherry

Natural peanut butter

Very good ,great price

- Jennifer

Creamy and Perfect

At my local grocery store, this item is at least double the price. I couldn't force myself to purchase it. When I saw it on Thrive Market, I squealed with delight! This item isn't too oily. It's creamy, but it doesn't get that oil pool when it has been sitting for a while. The bottle is about as tall as two apples standing on one another and about the same in width; this is only to give you an idea of the size. It's a great product, and I will be purchasing more in the future!!!

- Amanda


Creamy and tasty. I love to eat this with sliced apples or carrots. The perfect healthy snack.

- farrah


I'll be honest, since I've tried a couple of different types of butters from Justin's, I didn't read the label. After the first taste, I thought something was strange so THEN I read the label. This particular version doesn't have any sugar in it. However, it surprisingly yummy even without the sugar. I will most likely make the switch permanent.

- Angel


The best natural peanut butter!

- Cheryl Lynn

Great peanut butter

Taste like peanut butter should without all the sugar. Perfectly spreadable & no oil! Wonderful flavor! Yum

- Angela

My new favorite natural peanut butter

The other no-sugar brand I've been buying in the grocery store actually separates. This one does not.

- Lynn


I wanted to like this PB, but the texture isn't good. It's not creamy at all and hard to spread. Because there is no added sugar it's kind of bland...maybe the one with added honey would be better. Won't be ordering again...

- Christine

Great for smoothies

I switch between Justin's almond and peanut butter, but I love them both for my morning smoothies.

- Carry

Still on the fence

Good flavor, love that you don't have to refrigerate or stir...but not very spreadable

- mskay8


Great flavor. A texture between crunchy and creamy!

- Tara


This peanut butter is hands down my favorite! It actually tastes like peanuts and has ingredients you can read! :) Make sure you stir it up before you use it!

- Jade

Featured on Thrive Market

See All Articles
Natural Sources of Electrolytes

Natural Sources of Electrolytes

“Electrolytes” might sound like some futuristic sci-fi robot, but they’re actually very real compounds that have a great impact on the human body.

Read More
Make Spooky Spiders on a Log for a Healthy Halloween Treat

Make Spooky Spiders on a Log for a Healthy Halloween Treat

What’s scarier than ghouls and goblins, witches and wizards, or zombies and mummies? The buckets of sugary candy that trick-or-treaters bring home every Halloween.

Read More
Frozen Peanut Butter Banana Bites Recipe

Frozen Peanut Butter Banana Bites Recipe

Chocolate-covered frozen bananas are a summertime classic, but just because it's back to school, doesn't mean it's time to say goodbye. Assemble these little mini pops for a bite-sized after-schoo...

Read More