Organic Creamy Almond Butter - Lightly Toasted

16 oz jar

Retail Price: $24.99

Our Price: $17.95 (Save 28%)

16 oz jar

Why You’ll Love It

Once Again Nut Butter uses only the finest organic almonds available. Lightly Toasted Organic Unblanched Almonds are milled smooth to create our Lightly Toasted Almond Butter. This is a gluten-free and certified organic product.
SKU: 044082534619

About This Brand

Providing the health-conscious consumers with products of superior quality and integrity.Jeremy Thaler and Constance Potter met while establishing Mifflin Street Co-op in Madison, Wisconsin. They shared common belief in the importance of herbal supplements, worker-owned cooperatives, organic and sustainable farming and the power of community. Upon leaving Madison and moving to Rochester, New York, they established a worker cooperative distribution called Clear Eye Distribution, and a whole-grain bakery that also produced granola using a barrel roaster.A chance question from a friend, "You have a barrel roaster, why don't you use it to make peanut butter?" led Jeremy to the peanut butter business. In 1976, Once Again Nut Butter was born. When Jeremy and Connie left Rochester for a more rural area, they moved the company into their 800 square foot basement and manufactured peanut butter there until they purchased the current facility in 1981.Mission StatementOnce Again is a...
Shop The Brand


Lightly toasted unblanched organic almonds.

California residents: Learn more on Prop 65 warning. Disclaimer: Information, statements, and reviews regarding products have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. Results vary person to person, and there is no guarantee of specific results. Thrive Market assumes no liability for inaccuracies or misstatements about products.
Serving Size 2 tablespoon (30g) Servings Per Container 15

Amount Per Serving

Calories 190 Calories from Fat 150

% Daily Value*
Total Fat 17g 26%
Saturated Fat 1.5g 8%
Trans Fat 0g
Cholesterol 0mg 0%
Sodium 0mg 0%
Total Carbohydrate 6g 2%
Dietary Fiber 3g 12%
Sugars 2g
Protein 6g

Vitamin A 0%
Vitamin C 0%
Calcium 10%
Iron 6%

Oil separation occurs naturally. To prevent, stir and refrigerate or freeze.

Reviews For Organic Creamy Almond Butter - Lightly Toasted

Based on 23 Reviews

Sugar free and organic is THE best

I love this sugar free and organic nut butter, which is, I think, the best. Sugar is so harmful to one's brain and body, and inorganic can be as well. I love that Thrive has sugar free organic nut butters. I highly recommend this product. It is yummy, and healthy.

- Tanda

Delicious, but a bit runny

I really love the flavor of this nut butter, but it's thin and doesn't stay put. It doesn't matter what you put it on.

- Susan

Sugar free yummy almond butter

Most nut butters in grocery stores have sugar in them. This wonderful product doesn't, and it tastes wonderful. I love eating only organic foods as non-organic is not good for one's health and wellbeing. This is a marvelous product which I highly recommend. I eat an organic granny smith apple every day dipped in this almond butter. Yummy stuff:-)

- Tanda

Organic almond butter

Great taste!

- Gayle

Good flavor & consistency

I like this almond butter. It stays smooth, not too hard to spread.

- Tracey


I love it!

- Luisa

Creamy Almond Butter

The taste is very good, but I'm not crazy about the texture. Even after you stir it up it is still very pasty. You have to mix it very well to get a spreadable consistency, so be careful when opening the jar because all the liquid is on top.

- Virginia

Request chunky almond butter

I also prefer the chunky Once Again organic almond butter

- Jean

Favorite Almond Butter

I've tried so many different almond butters out there, but this is by far my favorite organic option! Thankful for the low price on Thrive!

- Lauren

Once Again Organic Creamy Almond Butter - Lightly Toasted

After trying many organic almond butters, this is my family's pick for the most delicious and easiest to stir. I hope Thrive will continue to provide this product because their packaging and shipping is wonderful! One suggestion, Thrive...please start carrying the chunky Once Again Almond Butter. That is our very favorite.

- Marci

Very Good!

So much better tasting than the Raw Almond Butter.
I use Raw for recipes, but when I eat it on an apple or banana, for a snack, this is the one I want.

- Tricia


I love this stuff! I add my own pink himalayan sea salt, about one 1/2 teaspoon, stir, and it's perfect! Suppose you could add a little stevia powder if you wanted it sweet too....I love that it is organic and the texture is wonderfully spreadable. The taste is outstanding! Just the right amount of nutty and salt. Mmmmmmm!

- Diana

Great Almond Butter

I love Once again almond butters. This is my favorite. It is almost raw in make which I really like and I love that it's organic. It isn't too sweet, but it's not bland either and is amazing on crackers and in over night oatmeal. A really great product!

- Oliver B.

Good-prefer the dry roasted

This almond butter has great flavor, but I prefer the dry roasted opposed to lightly toasted. This is still an incredible buy and great value with it's organic and gluten free make and is basically raw-which even with it's lightly toasted marketing doesn't bother me so much.

- Barbara S.

Nice, But Would Prefer Dry Roasted!

I saw the review from "L" and just wanted to say that I tried this lightly toasted almond butter and I agree that while it is a high-quality almond butter, it is very close to raw. I've bought the dry roasted version from Whole Foods and I think it's much tastier (and easier on the stomach, too). To the reviewer named Carol: you should try the dry roasted version. To Thrive Market: I agree with L. that you should carry the dry roasted organic creamy almond butter from Once Again! Thanks!

- Ellie

Great Brand, But Regular "Dry Roasted" Version is Better

I'm a huge fan of Once Again almond butter--I've tried it all, and I'm certain it's the highest quality, tastiest organic almond butter you can buy. The Thrive Market price is also competitive, considering how expensive organic almond butter can be. Unfortunately Thrive is only carrying the "Lightly Toasted" version, which, as other reviewers have noted, is very close to a raw almond butter. If you prefer raw, this is the one for you. But if you're looking for the taste of roasted almonds, and if you find roasted almond butter easier to digest (as I do!), the regular version of this very same almond butter--simply called "Organic Creamy Almond Butter"--is the better bet. The only ingredient is dry roasted (not merely "lightly toasted" organic almonds). It is MUCH easier on a sensitive digestive system, and to the reviewers who were looking for a fresh-ground almond butter taste, the dry roasted version is for you. I'm hoping Thrive Market will decide to carry the dry roasted version, since the price is certainly the best I can find online!

- L.

Once Again Creamy Almond Butter - Lightly Toasted

I have had freshly ground almond butter before and was pleased that this product didn't contain any other additives or preservatives. Unfortunately, this product just didn't taste fresh so I was disappointed with the taste.

- Carol

Protein packed butter

I have an allergy to peanuts, so eating almond butter is a great alternative when it comes to craving that creamy taste. I find that almond butter is not as sweet as peanut butter, but it has a deeper, more refined flavor that starts out as bland, but blends nicely with other stuff such as organic jam and organic honey. I also like to blend this in my smoothies to jack the protein level.

- Jean Claude

Nice almond flavor

If you like raw almonds, then you'll love this almond butter. It's not as creamy as peanut butter, but it has a nice crunchy taste and the flavor of almonds. It's more subtle than I'm used to, and it takes some getting used to, but once the almond flavor kicks in, you won't be able to put this butter down.

It's great on just about anything you can imagine, and probably some things you haven't such as celery sticks and bananas.

- Jeannette Zimmerman

Expensive But Worth It

I've been so used to peanut butters that I decided to give a peanut butter alternative a try. That's where almond butter came in. At first, I hated it. It doesn't taste nearly as sweet as peanut butter. But I gave up the PB habit and continued with this, and the taste grew on me. Now my peanut butter tastes like really thick syrup. I prefer the taste of almond butter now.

My only complaint is that this can get really expensive. It's just how much the manufacturer charges for it. In fact, Thrive is the lowest price I've ever seen on it. I love this butter, but I definitely wish it wasn't so expensive.

- Akali

Smooth and crunchy

I really like this kind of butter spread. It's smooth but has crunchy bits of almonds. It tastes amazing and goes well with toasts, sandwiches and alone too. It’s super healthy just like any other product from this brand. I will definitely keep buying this product and will try some of their other products too.

- Henrietta Guerrero

Healthy and travel-friendly!

There is no sugar or salt or anything else...JUST ALMONDS and it tastes exactly like raw almonds, that's it!!! I travel a lot for work and order this to eat with apples or straight from the jar as a snack. So delicious and good for you!

- P. H.

Will buy this again

Yes, I tried this partly due to the cute raccoon on the label, but it's also an incredibly natural product. Sodium free, unsweetened, organic, and non-GMO. I really enjoyed the lightly toasted almond flavor. It's great for my paleo diet!

- A. Day

Featured on Thrive Market

See All Articles
The Ultimate Paleo Diet Food List

The Ultimate Paleo Diet Food List

It’s official—the Paleo diet has hit the tipping point. Although this prehistoric eating regimen, also known as “primal” eating, has been in the zeitgeist for years (it was Google’s most-searched t...

Read More
16 Staple Ingredients For Every Paleo Household

16 Staple Ingredients For Every Paleo Household

Converting to a Paleo or primal lifestyle means, among other things, you'll be spending a lot more time cooking. To really be sure you're getting the best, wholesome meals, it's best to make them y...

Read More
Egg and Spinach Breakfast Muffins Recipe

Egg and Spinach Breakfast Muffins Recipe

Pancake mixes are great for whipping up a foolproof stack of flapjacks, but ever wonder what to do with the leftover mix? Especially if you overindulged don’t want to see another pancake for a whi...

Read More