Creamy Peanut Butter - Dark Roasted

16 oz jar

Retail Price: $7.29

Our Price: $4.95 (Save 32%)

16 oz jar

Why You’ll Love It

Santa Cruz Organic Creamy Dark Roasted Peanut Butter is made with USDA certified organic Spanish peanuts and less than 1 percent salt. The unique recipe contains no hydrogenated oils, added sugars, or artificial ingredients. Each serving offers a good amount of iron, seven grams of protein, two grams of dietary fiber, and healthy fats.
SKU: 036192127003

About This Brand

The first company to offer a wide range of organic, 100 percent juices and blends.The Santa Cruz Organic® brand's roots stretch back to the early 1970's when founder and nature lover, John Battendieri, began revitalizing orchards in the Santa Cruz mountains, an area known for its high-quality, flavorful fruit. Battendieri pressed his first batch of "Mr. Natural" apple juice in 1972, making it one of the first packaged organic products.About Santa Cruz OrganicAs a pioneer organic brand, Santa Cruz Organic® was the first company to offer customers a wide range of organic, 100 percent juices and blends. We were also the first juice processor to use all organic fruit. As a company, we believe nature itself is the truest form of art, and our goal is to infuse the beauty of nature's process into everything we do … from harvest to the bottle on your table.Santa Cruz Organic® currently offers more than 50 organic items ranging from organic fruit juices and lemonades to organic fruit sauces,...
Shop The Brand


Organic Roasted Peanuts, Contains 1% Or Less Of Salt.

California residents: Learn more on Prop 65 warning. Disclaimer: Information, statements, and reviews regarding products have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. Results vary person to person, and there is no guarantee of specific results. Thrive Market assumes no liability for inaccuracies or misstatements about products.
Serving Size 2 Tbsp (32g) Servings Per Container about 14

Amount Per Serving

Calories 210 Calories from Fat 140

% Daily Value*
Total Fat 17g 26%
Saturated Fat 2.5g 12%
Trans Fat 0g
Cholesterol 0mg 0%
Sodium 50mg 2%
Total Carbohydrate 6g 2%
Dietary Fiber 2g 9%
Sugars 1g
Protein 7g

Iron 2%

Reviews For Creamy Peanut Butter - Dark Roasted

Based on 68 Reviews


To deal with the separation, we keep it in in and out of the fridge, especially when the jar is full and it is difficult to stir.

- Ralitza

Santa Cruz Organic Creamy Peanut Butter - Dark Roasted

Best peanut butter EVER!

- Grubb


Bought this in the dead of winter and it arrived on its side in the box. I had to wait until it reached room temp before attempting to stir - no biggie! What surprised me was that it didn't separate again. Maybe a little greasy on top but certainly nothing major. It's delicious but not smokey like I had expected from anything labeled "dark roast". But then again, I drink French roast coffee so maybe my taste buds aren't as sensitive anymore? Haha! Anyway, I don't keep it in the fridge despite the directions. I will definitely be purchasing this again.

- VB

Best peanut butter

Tastes like a handful of delicious peanuts!

- Carole

simply delicious

I've been looking for a peanut butter with just peanuts in it and I found this. It's delicious and smooth and everything I love about peanut butter!

- Lucia

Ummmm... what can I say?

It's really very inconvenient to have to store PB in refrigerator. Makes it much to thick to spread, and to top it off, the taste is NOT that great...


Great tasting peanut butter

It taste so good and satisfies!

- Donald


I used to use a very similar peanut butter made by a more mainstream brand, until I found out that it contained traces of GMO corn, yuck! I'm much happier with this one. Not only do I notice a difference in the taste, but I also find that I tolerate it much better.


- Ivonne Marmolejo

Tasty and healthy

Improves diet and every bit helps.

- Kenneth

So So Good

The taste is what one should expect from really good peanut butter. The stuff is so good that it should be illegal to sell any other brand!

- James

Our Favorite Peanut Butter

We go through this like mad. The taste is the absolute best, and the consistency is a little thinner, making it perfect for smoothies and super easy to spread on sandwiches. My kids think other thicker, sugarier peanut butters are weird, and I have to agree!

- Amie


This is my kids' favorite kind of peanut butter. Love the dark roasted flavor and no sugar! They gobble it up.

- Jane

Great taste, Hard to spread

I like this peanut butter, really I do. It tastes great and hits all the value categories that are important to me. Unfortunately it must be refrigerated after opening and thus gets very firm and hard to spread on bread. I've curtailed this some by leaving it in the door (warmest part of the fridge) and taking it out before using it but it's still pretty dense. Overall I think it's great!

- Seth


Best Peanut Butter ever.....Try it soon...

- Alice


Utterly delicious! Among the best peanut butter EVER!

- Linda


A great nut butter, extra flavorful.

- Emily

Organic creamy peanut butter

Excellent product, very good price.


Santa Cruz is the Best!

This is my favorite peanut butter. I have bought dozens of jars. Really love the good price.

- Wendy

cannot beat this

tastes good and cannot get organic for less!

- Kenneth



- Carole

The Best... Can't be beat

So Solid and rich in flavor. A shopping list favorite.

- Connie

Love it

This is the ideal PB for smoothies--it's a little runnier than others (so maybe not ideal for sandwiches), but the dark roasted flavor is great.

- Amie

Overall really good.

Price aside, the flavor is good. Mixes well, and the knowledge of organic peanuts is comforting. However Wholefoods has a couple of pretty good, less expensive alternatives that are also organic.

- Peter

santa cruz organic peanut butter

very very tasty

- pablo

Good But Not Best

The Santa Cruz Dark Roasted Creamy Peanut Butter is quite good, but the smooth peanut butters from Woodstock and Field Day are superior in flavor if not price.

- Julianne Gressley and David Grässle


I have ordered this over and over! It is the BEST!

- seashell

Peanut butter

The most natural tasting peanut butter I have ever had.Love it!1

- Kathy


That's it, just so yummmmm.

- Donna

Yummy peanut butter and very healthy for you

I use this peanut butter often as I believe in using organic products. It is delicious and very healthy.

- Tanda


Good flavor, not too salty.

- Susan

My Favorite Peanut Butter

Peanuts and salt. That's it and that's all that is needed. No oils, no sugars. The dark roasting adds a nice depth of flavor. This has been my go-to peanut butter for years.

- Tina



- Jessica

My staple Peanut Butter

I've chosen this brand for a few years, now. I like the flavor, the "only peanuts" ingredients and it is nice to get it consistently discounted. I do not like sugar or other additives in my peanut butter.

- Wendy G.


No sugar added. I've been used to sugar laden peanut butter and you can tell this has no additives...which is a good thing!

- Jessica

Best 1-ingredient PB!

Best peanut butter I've ever tasted that only has one ingredients - the peanuts! (:

- Allison

Very delicious!

This peanut butter has two ingredients; dark roasted peanuts and salt. You can't get any simpler than that. And this peanut butter lived up to all the reviews. Great flavor, great texture and easy to spread. Be sure to stir well and then refrigerate. You will not need to stir again.

- Cynthia

Great Peanut Butter

My whole family loves this creamy PB. It does separate, but aside from that, it's perfect. Rich flavor, and super easy to spread.

- Amie

Great flavor

My family loves this peanut butter. Great taste from the dark roasted nuts and no added sugar. The kids had the jar gone in about a week!

- Jane

Wish you offered the Light Roasted!

This is a delicious, nutritious peanut butter! But the light-roasted version is even more nutritious! Hope you begin to carry that one soon. Thanks!

- Emily

Best organic peanut butter!!

Love that it is a glass jar and the oil blends well!

- Amanda

Santa Cruz Organic Peanut Butter

Really loved the flavor. Great product and price. Will absolutely buy again.

- Jeannine


best pb in the world

- Crissy

Santa Cruz organic dark roasted peanut butter

Good price. Too oily

- Dorothy

USDA Organic Peanut Butter

This is really good peanut butter!

- JJ


I have used this for years. It is simply the best peanut butter I have ever tasted and I have tasted a lot.

- Helga

Tasty and cheap

Great product, wish they had sprouted peanut butter... one day! but until then this is great bang for your buck for some tasty cooked/roasted peanut.

- Christopher


Our family's favorite!

- GS

Great Taste

This is the best tasting peanut butter out there and Organic to boot......

- Dorothy

Yum in a jar

This stuff is great. It has a depth of flavor due to the dark roasting (I think), that makes it different from my other natural PB.

- Dina

My favorite peanut butter

Excellent, rich taste. My favorite peanut butter by far

- Jen

A bit too oily for my taste.

I'm sorry. I thought I was going to really like this, but I have been trying to get some of the oil out of the butter ever since I opened it... and yes, that's after I mixed it up thoroughly. It just has a higher oil content than I like. Flavor is good.

- Rebecca


Rich flavor!

- D

Was expecting more sweetness.

I had a pretty good idea that this 'dark roast' would give off a smokey taste to this peanut butter. It was definitely a different touch but I enjoyed it. However, I was also expecting it to be at least mildly sweet, yet that was completely missing.

Mixing the oil every time to arrive at the right consistency is not even an issue but not tasting any sweetness in the peanut butter is difficult to get used to when I've only had sweet peanut butter all my life.

- J. Thomas

The ultimate peanut butter

I've been avoiding heavily processed foods and artificial ingredients whenever I can and I was so excited when my boyfriend brought home some of this peanut butter. He's still getting on board for the switch to healthier foods but I thought it was so cute that he'd venture over to the health store, take a look around, and pick some things out for me. It's hilarious because he really had no idea what he was doing, but he picked a good one! He went to open it and almost dumped out all the oil at the top. Luckily I stopped him in time to explain but after I'd stirred it all in, we absolutely loved it! I'd never heard of dark roasted peanuts before, but it sounded exactly up my alley and it did not disappoint. I kept it in the fridge after we'd had our fill and I haven't had to mix it since. I love the rich, smoky flavor it has, almost like it was ever so slightly caramelized.
Aside from the flavor, l like everything else about this product too. It's organic, it has 1 ingredient, it comes in a jar, and the cost is comparable to the store brand nut butters that are loaded with sugars and preservatives and artificial flavoring. It's a win-win-win-win!

- Annie B.

PB&J Sandwiches on Paleo Wrap

I LOVE this peanut butter! I bought it so that I could put it on my Paleo wrap for little extra coconut flavor. This butter is darker than I am used to which gives it a little smokier flavor. This is one of my favorite spreads hands down. Its Certified Organic and Non-GMO which is awesome!

I don't love that this product is made in Chico, CA but branded as Santa Cruz. I understand that it is just a name but makes it a little confusing. I would buy this product again regardless.

- Charles King

Too delicious!

My absolute favorite peanut butter! You really can't go wrong with this product, it's delicious, GMO free, and organic! I'm constantly looking for new reasons to use this and when I can't come up with anything I simply eat it by the spoon full.

- W. Potter

Creamy Peanut butter - dark roasted

This was the first time I bought P.B w. oil on top and read to keep it in fridge- but I don't mind.
It tastes sooo much better than those from store
when you don't know what's keeping them 'creamy'

I like that brand. will order again

- Evelyn

Best Natural Peanut Butter

Delicious! Even by the spoonful!

- Victoria

Delicious and Clean

This nut butter is free of the "extra stuff" that lurks in our nut butters. It's a great price and delicious texture.

- Kayln

Good taste

This dark roasted peanut butter has a very unique taste. It is delicious with fruits and vegetables. It makes a great sandwich.

The only thing I don't like, which is a problem with most organic peanut butter, is the separation. It's a pain stirring that oil back in. But the taste is worth the effort.

- Marcy Vincent

Rich and delicious

This was my first time trying dark roasted peanut butter and I have to say that I am impressed. Great, thick, rich flavor. This is better than your average peanut butter.

To me, this is like a gourmet peanut butter. I use this for many things, but my favorite is to just eat it by the spoon full.

- Steph Mussel

Rich and Creamy

I wasn't expecting much of a difference between this peanut butter and any other peanut butters. This really is the best of the best. It has a more smokey flavor that is just perfect. I love this particular peanut butter on toast and with my veggies. It is just plain delicious. I could eat a whole jar in one sitting if I wanted to. (though self control is a good thing!) I did notice the first time I opened it that it was a little separated, but after stirring it with a knife quickly it really stood up well and I haven't had to stir it since. This is truly a delicious peanut butter!

- Stacy M.

New Favorite

I love my peanut butter. I love peanut butter cookies, peanut butter on celery, peanut butter toast, much more! I even like it plain. I am really impressed with this particular brand of organic peanut butter. It is high quality and the nice smoky, rich flavor is to die for. I like to keep a few jars of this in the house because I find I use quite a lot of it!

- Steven Daniel

Toasted Peanut Taste

I had never heard of a dark roasted peanut butter, but I'm glad I gave it a try! It has a much more "smokey" flavor than standard peanut butter. It honestly tastes a whole lot more indulgent and filling than standard PB. You'll need to thoroughly mix this up once you get it before you eat it. Unlike non-organic kinds, this stuff can separate a bit and require you to stir it back up to get the proper taste. I've only had to mix it up when initially opening the jar, though. It doesn't seem to require mixing it very often.

- Mikal

Peanut butter for purists

If you're into pure peanut butter that has nothing added, this is the ticket.

I confess I was kind of raised on salty peanut butter with additives and for years, that was my first choice. Then I got healthy and decided it was time to seek a more healthy peanut butter spread.

Enter this dark roasted wonder that has spanish nuts and pretty much nothing else. It's not sweet, and the flavor is rich and has a slight smoky edge to it. I use it on bread, fruit and as a topping for my pancakes.

- Addison

Best peanut butter on the planet

Yes, I think this is easily the best peanut butter I've ever tasted. Santa Cruz also makes a light roast, but I prefer the stronge flavor of dark roasted peanuts.

This is thick, creamy peanut butter that's made from organic nuts. It's much less sweet than Jiffy or Skippy, and low in salt and has no hydrogenated oils.

Basically, they took organic nuts, made them into a paste and added nothing. That's pure greatness.

- Albeta Owens

Dark Rosted Peanut Butter, Yes Please!

What a treat from ordinary peanut butter! I love the taste of this dark roast. The fact that it's organic with no sugar or oils added, is a bonus.

This peanut butter is great for a new kind of PBJ, but it's really a versatile spread. Try it with fruit slices like apples or pears. It goes great in an almond milk smoothie and on toast, waffles and so much more. I put it on celery the other day for "ants on a log"!

- Vincent Swanson


Dark roasted peanut butter? This was a new concept to me. I thought peanut butter was pretty standard, except for natural vs. conventional. Since I'm a PB fanatic, I decided to give this a try, and it is awesome! It has a rich, deep flavor that has caused me to switch over for life. Like dark chocolate, it's probably not for everyone, but it certainly is for me.

- Candice Blair

Featured on Thrive Market

See All Articles
Healthified 'Snickers' Bars Recipe

Healthified 'Snickers' Bars Recipe

When a sugar craving strikes, ignoring it is out of the question. Or at least it feels that way. Next time you can't stop thinking about chocolate, satisfy your hunger with a healthier option—like...

Read More
Ask a Nutritionist: 3 New Ways to Use Prunes

Ask a Nutritionist: 3 New Ways to Use Prunes

Prunes have an image problem. Yes, your grandma might use them for a little digestive relief, but these dried fruits aren't just for the geriatric set. They're actually pretty tasty—and they're pac...

Read More
8 Quick Swaps To Healthify Your Breakfast and Lunch

8 Quick Swaps To Healthify Your Breakfast and Lunch

There's no quick fix for losing weight. However, there are a few quick swaps you can make to change your diet.

Read More