Peanut butter might be the O.G. spread, but inventive nut butters—made with everything from pistachios to oats—have popped up to offer even more variety. 
What Are Alternative Nut Butters

Nut butter—a creamy spread made with nuts—is a popular pantry staple, and for good reason. From sandwiches and dressings to smoothies and desserts, there’s almost nothing it can’t do. Nut butter alternatives take things to the next level, either by using less popular nuts (like Brazil or hazelnuts), or non-nut ingredients (like oats and hemp seeds) that create a similar consistency or texture.
Top Alternative Nut Butter Brands

Nut butter without the nuts? Oat Haus is serving up something new. 
Oat Haus

Oat Haus takes oatmeal to new heights with a jar that’s reminiscent of your favorite spread, just without the nuts. Plus, everything is soy- and dairy-free, and made with organic ingredients. 
Best Alternative Nut Butters

No need to pick a favorite—every flavor is worth savoring.
Oat Haus Granola Butter, Original

To make their base recipe, Oat Haus uses a combination of gluten-free oats, olive oil, and coconut oil that’s seasoned with allspice, cardamom, and ginger. Every bite is sweetened with maple syrup, and Thrive Market member Amanda from Kansas says “this stuff is so good and has great ingredients! Beware it’s addicting.”
Oat Haus Granola Butter, Vanilla

For a slight spin on the original, reach for a spoonful of vanilla-flavored butter. Cristie from Tennessee uses it for her kids who attend a school that doesn’t allow nuts, and Samantha from Washington simply says: “Try this and thank me later!”
Granola Butter, Birthday Cake

Make every day a celebration with Oat Haus’s birthday cake-inspired recipe mixed with sprinkles that have been colored with fruits and vegetables. Erin from Texas says “Hands down my favorite flavor. Thrive Market turned me onto this brand, and with a peanut and nut allergy, I had to try this unique alternative to peanut butter.”
Top Nut Butter Recipes from Thrive Market

In the Thrive Market test kitchen, we’ve never met a nut butter we didn’t like. Here are some of our favorite recipes that go beyond peanuts and almonds. 
Homemade Pistachio Nut Butter

With just a few simple ingredients (and a food processor) you can enjoy this rich and creamy pistachio butter that’s flavored with a hint of vanilla. 
Coconut Cashew Date Bars

This no-bake recipe features shredded coconut, sweet dates, raw cashews, and luscious coconut butter for an on-the-go snack you can enjoy any time of day. 
DIY Nutella Recipe

If you love a hazelnut spread, try this easy recipe to make a batch at home using just three ingredients: hazelnut flour, chocolate chips, and almond milk.

<p>Peanut butter might be the O.G. spread, but inventive nut butters—made with everything from pistachios to oats—have popped up to offer even more variety.</p> 
<h2>What Are Alternative Nut Butters</h2>

<p>Nut butter—a creamy spread made with nuts—is a popular pantry staple, and for good reason. From sandwiches and dressings to smoothies and desserts, there’s <a href="https://thrivemarket.com/blog/almond-butter-is-so-much-more-than-a-toast-topper-here-are-4-ideas"target="_blank">almost nothing it can’t do</a>. Nut butter alternatives take things to the next level, either by using less popular nuts (like Brazil or hazelnuts), or non-nut ingredients (like oats and hemp seeds) that create a similar consistency or texture.</p>
<h2>Top Alternative Nut Butter Brands</h2>

<p>Nut butter without the nuts? Oat Haus is serving up something new.</p> 
<h3>Oat Haus</h3>

<p>Oat Haus takes oatmeal to new heights with a jar that’s reminiscent of your favorite spread, just without the nuts. Plus, everything is soy- and dairy-free, and made with organic ingredients.</p> 
<h2>Best Alternative Nut Butters</h2>

<p>No need to pick a favorite—every flavor is worth savoring.</p>
<h3>Oat Haus Granola Butter, Original</h3>

<p><a href="https://thrivemarket.com/p/oat-haus-granola-butter-original"target="_blank">To make their base recipe</a>, Oat Haus uses a combination of gluten-free oats, olive oil, and coconut oil that’s seasoned with allspice, cardamom, and ginger. Every bite is sweetened with maple syrup, and Thrive Market member Amanda from Kansas says “this stuff is so good and has great ingredients! Beware it’s addicting.”</p>
<h3>Oat Haus Granola Butter, Vanilla</h3>

<p>For a slight spin on the original, reach for a spoonful of <a href="https://thrivemarket.com/p/oat-haus-granola-butter-vanilla"target="_blank">vanilla-flavored butter</a>. Cristie from Tennessee uses it for her kids who attend a school that doesn’t allow nuts, and Samantha from Washington simply says: “Try this and thank me later!”</p>
<h3>Granola Butter, Birthday Cake</h3>

<p>Make every day a celebration with <a href="https://thrivemarket.com/p/oat-haus-granola-butter-birthday-cake"target="_blank">Oat Haus’s birthday cake-inspired recipe</a> mixed with sprinkles that have been colored with fruits and vegetables. Erin from Texas says “Hands down my favorite flavor. <a href="https://thrivemarket.com"target="_blank">Thrive Market</a> turned me onto this brand, and with a peanut and nut allergy, I had to try this unique alternative to peanut butter.”</p>
<h2>Top Nut Butter Recipes from Thrive Market</h2>

<p>In the Thrive Market test kitchen, we’ve never met a nut butter we didn’t like. Here are some of our favorite recipes that go beyond peanuts and almonds.</p> 
<h3>Homemade Pistachio Nut Butter</h3>

<p>With just a few simple ingredients (and a food processor) you can enjoy this <a href="https://thrivemarket.com/blog/how-to-make-homemade-pistachio-nut-butter-3-ways"target="_blank">rich and creamy pistachio butter</a> that’s flavored with a hint of vanilla.</p> 
<h3>Coconut Cashew Date Bars</h3>

<p><a href="https://thrivemarket.com/blog/video-no-bake-coconut-cashew-date-bars-are-a-dream-come-true"target="_blank">This no-bake recipe</a> features shredded coconut, sweet dates, raw cashews, and luscious coconut butter for an on-the-go snack you can enjoy any time of day.</p> 
<h3>DIY Nutella Recipe</h3>

<p>If you love a hazelnut spread, <a href="https://thrivemarket.com/blog/diy-nutella-recipe"target="_blank">try this easy recipe</a> to make a batch at home using just three ingredients: hazelnut flour, chocolate chips, and almond milk.</p> 

Buy alternative nut butters online at Thrive Market. Save time and money and get the best healthy groceries delivered. Free shipping on most orders!

Buy Alternative Nut Butters Online

All Alternative Nut Butters

Chocolate & Hazelnut Spreads

Jam, Jellies & Preserves

Nut Butters

Seed Butters

Alternative Nut Butters

Gluten-Free

Paleo

Vegan

Vegetarian

Ketogenic

AIP Diet

Low FODMAP

Organic

Whole30® Compatible

Mediterranean Diet

Plant-Based Perfection: How to Make a Vegan Burger

Keto vs. Atkins

6 Gluten-Free Recipes & Pantry Staples This Member Can’t Live Without

Shop By

Food

Vitamins & Supplements

Meat & Seafood

Home

Bath & Body

Babies & Kids

Beauty

Top Rated

What's New

2 Paleo Recipes That Bring Out the Best in Our Thrive Market Avocado Honey

How To Cook Spatchcock Chicken

Thrive Market Goods

Non-GMO

Big 9 Allergen-Free

Certified Organic

Certified Gluten-Free

Frozen

Wine

Shopping Lists

Bundle & Save

Baking

Bars

Beverages

Candy & Chocolate

Canned & Packaged Food

Cereals & Granolas

Condiments & Sauces

Ghee, Oils & Vinegars

Grains, Pasta & Bread

Honey & Sweeteners

Nut Butters & Fruit Spreads

Snacks

Soups, Meals & Side Dishes

Spices, Seasoning & Salt

Our Baking Supplies

What’s New

9 Pumpkin Spice Recipes to Make This Fall

Minimize Food Waste by Getting Strategic

Whole30 Approved®

Non-GMO Project Verified

Dairy-Free

Appetizers & Snacks

Bread & Dough

Breakfast Foods

Frozen Desserts

Fruit & Vegetables

Meals

Pasta

Pizza

Plant-Based Meat

Prepared Meat & Seafood

Soups and Broths

Frozen Foods

Pasture-Raised

Sustainably Caught

Free-Range

Made in USA

Family-Owned Business

Grass-Fed

No Antibiotics / Synthetic Hormones

Beef

Poultry

Pork

Seafood

Lamb

Easy Salmon Recipes

Lemon Pepper Chicken Wings 2 Ways: Air-Fried and Baked

Amino Acids

Antioxidants

Collagen

Herbs & Homeopathy

Hemp Extract

Letter Vitamins

Men's Health

Minerals

Multivitamins

Omegas & Fish Oils

Probiotics & Digestion

Sports Nutrition

Superfoods & Greens

Women's Health

Our Vitamins & Supplements

Why It’s Important to Buy USDA Certified Organic Hemp Extract

Boost Your Gut Health on the Keto Diet With ORGANIC INDIA’s Psyllium Husk

Vitamins

Soy-Free

Diapering

Baby & Kids Food

Moms & Maternity

Toys

Our Diapers & Wipes

Healthy Homeschool Snacks for Every Craving

7 Quick, Easy, Fun, and Healthy Recipes to Cook With Your Kids

Dye- and Color Additive-Free

Fragrance-Free

Phthalate-Free

Body Care

Essential Oils & Aromatherapy

Period Care

First Aid

Hair Care

Men's Grooming

Oral Care

Sexual Health

Shaving & Hair Removal

Soap & Bath

Sun & Bug

Best Sellers

DIY Reusable Face Wipes

DIY Gua Sha Oil

Cruelty-Free

Paraben-Free

SLS-Free

Cleaning

Fermentation

Home Accessories

Household Supplies

Kitchenware

Laundry

Yoga & Home Fitness

Low Waste Living

15 Best Eco-Friendly Products + Gift Ideas

How to Stock an Eco-Friendly Laundry Room

BPA-Free

Essential Oils

Skincare

Fragrance

Lip Care

Makeup

Men's Skincare

Nails

Beauty Gift Sets

5-Minute DIY Manuka Honey Face Masks

What is an Ayurvedic Beauty Routine?

EWG Verified

Cider & Hard Pressed Juice 

Curated Bundles

Red Wine

Rosé Wine

Sparkling Wine

White Wine

3 Ways to Cook With Leftover Wine

Red Wine Hot Cacao Recipe

Cat Food

Cat Treats

Cat Vitamins & Supplements

Dog Flea & Tick

Dog Food

Dog Grooming

Dog Potty & Cleaning

Dog Toys & Accessories

Dog Treats

Dog Vitamins & Supplements

How to Prep for a New Dog or Cat

10 Nontoxic Pet-Friendly Cleaning Products

Grain-Free

Staff Picks

Pumpkin Season

Fall Flavors

Football-Watching Food

Back to School

Return to Routine

New Lower Price

Trending Now

Exclusives

Gift Guide

Gift Cards

Gift Boxes

Gifts