If eyes are the window to the soul, the last thing you want to do is cover them in chemical-laden makeup. It especially pays to be particular about eyeliner—aside from mascara, no other product gets as close to the eye itself (not to mention the fact that the skin around the eyes is more delicate). Ideally, you want something plant-based and non-irritating. Yet most conventional eyeliners are made with chemicals and artificial ingredients that don’t do your skin any favors. The good news is that there are gentler, more natural eyeliner options out there—formulas made with vitamin E, aloe, and other nourishing ingredients. Read on for our favorite brands and product picks. 
Top Natural Eyeliner Brands

These three brands make it easy to go natural, even with eyeliner.
Mineral Fusion

Pick up your multitasking essentials from Mineral Fusion, and you’ll be opting for nourishing ingredients rather than parabens, artificial colors, or other harsh chemicals.
W3LL People

Botanical-based formulas are the name of the game for this modern line focused on simple, high-performance products.
Best Non-Toxic Eyeliners

With so many eyeliners to choose from, it can be hard to pick a favorite! Luckily, you don’t have to. These three are the best non-toxic eyeliners around.
Mineral Fusion Coal Eye Pencil

This mineral-based pencil is formulated with chamomile, meadowfoam, and vitamin E. The rich coal color makes it easy to achieve the ultimate smokey eye. 
No Miss Cosmetics Black Diamond Liquid Eyeliner

Rich in herbal extracts and enriched with aloe and vitamin E for an extra dose of moisture, this eyeliner also boasts a fragrance-free formula that’s safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.
W3LL People Expressionist Liquid Eyeliner

Don’t fear liquid eyeliner—here’s a plant-based version perfect for creating defined looks that are water-resistant and smudge-proof. The felt-tip applicator makes achieving the perfect cat eye practically effortless. 
You Might Like

DIY eyeliner? Oh yes. Plus, glam holiday looks and the best makeup brushes.
Best Makeup Brushes for That Natural Look

Go natural with our lineup of favorite brushes, bronzers, foundations, eyeshadows, and more.
W3LL People Has Your Ticket to Glam Holiday Makeup

Don’t let all the decorating and shopping get in the way of feeling your most festive. These eight must-have products will help you put your freshest face forward. 
How to Make DIY Eyeliner

Almonds are the secret ingredient in this DIY eyeliner, which you can whip up at home with only a few ingredients.

<p>If eyes are the window to the soul, the last thing you want to do is cover them in chemical-laden makeup. It especially pays to be particular about eyeliner—aside from mascara, no other product gets as close to the eye itself (not to mention the fact that the skin around the eyes is more delicate). Ideally, you want something plant-based and non-irritating. Yet most conventional eyeliners are made with chemicals and artificial ingredients that don’t do your skin any favors. The good news is that there are gentler, more natural eyeliner options out there—formulas made with vitamin E, aloe, and other nourishing ingredients. Read on for our favorite brands and product picks. </p>
<h2>Top Natural Eyeliner Brands</h2>

<p>These three brands make it easy to go natural, even with eyeliner.</p>
<h3><a href="https://thrivemarket.com/brand/mineral-fusion"target="_blank">Mineral Fusion</a></h3>

<p>Pick up your multitasking essentials from Mineral Fusion, and you’ll be opting for nourishing ingredients rather than parabens, artificial colors, or other harsh chemicals.</p>
<h3><a href="https://thrivemarket.com/brand/w3ll-people"target="_blank">W3LL People</a></h3>

<p>Botanical-based formulas are the name of the game for this modern line focused on simple, high-performance products.</p>
<h2>Best Non-Toxic Eyeliners</h2>

<p>With so many eyeliners to choose from, it can be hard to pick a favorite! Luckily, you don’t have to. These three are the best non-toxic eyeliners around.</p>
<h3><a href="https://thrivemarket.com/p/mineral-fusion-coal-eye-pencil"target="_blank">Mineral Fusion Coal Eye Pencil</a></h3>

<p>This mineral-based pencil is formulated with chamomile, meadowfoam, and vitamin E. The rich coal color makes it easy to achieve the ultimate smokey eye. </p>
<h3>No Miss Cosmetics Black Diamond Liquid Eyeliner</h3>

<p>Rich in herbal extracts and enriched with aloe and vitamin E for an extra dose of moisture, this eyeliner also boasts a fragrance-free formula that’s safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.</p>
<h3><a href="https://thrivemarket.com/p/w3ll-people-expressionist-liquid-eyeliner"target="_blank">W3LL People Expressionist Liquid Eyeliner</a></h3>

<p>Don’t fear liquid eyeliner—here’s a plant-based version perfect for creating defined looks that are water-resistant and smudge-proof. The felt-tip applicator makes achieving the perfect cat eye practically effortless. </p>
<h2>You Might Like</h2>

<p>DIY eyeliner? Oh yes. Plus, glam holiday looks and the best makeup brushes.</p>
<h3><a href="https://thrivemarket.com/blog/best-makeup-brushes-for-natural-look"target="_blank">Best Makeup Brushes for That Natural Look</a></h3>

<p>Go natural with our lineup of favorite brushes, bronzers, foundations, eyeshadows, and more.</p>
<h3><a href="https://thrivemarket.com/blog/w3ll-people-has-your-ticket-to-glamorous-holiday-makeup"target="_blank">W3LL People Has Your Ticket to Glam Holiday Makeup</a></h3>

<p>Don’t let all the decorating and shopping get in the way of feeling your most festive. These eight must-have products will help you put your freshest face forward. </p>
<h3><a href="https://thrivemarket.com/blog/diy-eyeliner-recipe"target="_blank">How to Make DIY Eyeliner</a></h3>

<p>Almonds are the secret ingredient in this DIY eyeliner, which you can whip up at home with only a few ingredients.</p>

Buy eyeliner online at Thrive Market. Save time and money, and get the best beauty supplies delivered. Free shipping on most orders!

Buy Eyeliner Online

All Makeup

Cheeks

Eyes

Face

Lips

Makeup Brushes & Accessories

Makeup Remover

Eyeliner

Gluten-Free

Vegan

Organic

Ketogenic

Vegetarian

GLP-1 Friendly

Paleo

Whole30® Compatible

Mediterranean Diet

Low FODMAP

AIP Diet

Plant-Based Perfection: How to Make a Vegan Burger

Keto vs. Atkins

6 Gluten-Free Recipes & Pantry Staples This Member Can’t Live Without

Shop By

Food

Vitamins & Supplements

Meat & Seafood

Home

Bath & Body

Babies & Kids

Beauty

What's New

2 Paleo Recipes That Bring Out the Best in Our Thrive Market Avocado Honey

How To Cook Spatchcock Chicken

Top Rated

Thrive Market Goods

Non-GMO

Big 9 Allergen-Free

Certified Organic

Certified Gluten-Free

Featured Finds

Bestsellers

New Lower Price

Holiday Favorites

New Year's Resolutions

Booze-Free Beverages

New Kids' Picks

Winter Beauty, Bath & Body

Immunity & Cold Care

Trending Now

Pantry

Snacks, Bars & Treats

Beverages

Frozen

Health & Wellness

Personal Care

Household

Non-Alcoholic Drinks

Beef

Poultry

Pork

Seafood

Lamb & Game

Lemon Pepper Chicken Wings 2 Ways: Air-Fried and Baked

Easy Salmon Recipes

Baking

Canned & Packaged Foods

Cereals & Granolas

Condiments & Sauces

Ghee, Oils & Vinegars

Grains, Pasta & Bread

Honey & Sweeteners

Nut Butters & Fruit Spreads

Soups, Meals & Side Dishes

Spices, Seasoning & Salt

Our Baking Supplies

What’s New

9 Pumpkin Spice Recipes to Make This Fall

Minimize Food Waste by Getting Strategic

Whole30 Approved®

Non-GMO Project Verified

Dairy-Free

Bars

Candy & Chocolate

Snacks

Cocktail Mixers

Coconut Water

Coffee

Coffee Creamer

Functional & Energy Drinks

Hot Chocolate

Juice & Nectar

Kids' Drinks

Milk Alternatives

Protein Drinks

Smoothie & Drink Mixes

Sodas & Sparkling Juices

Water & Sparkling Water

Ethically Sourced

Certified Kosher

Certified Fairly Traded

Sustainably Farmed

Caffeine-Free

Appetizers & Snacks

Frozen Bread & Dough

Breakfast Foods

Frozen Desserts

Frozen Fruit & Vegetables

Meals

Frozen Meat & Seafood

Pasta

Pizza

Plant-Based Meat & Seafood

Prepared Meat & Seafood

Bundle & Save

Pasture-Raised

Sustainably Caught

Free-Range

Made in USA

Family-Owned Business

Grass-Fed

No Antibiotics / Synthetic Hormones

Non-Alcoholic Beer

Non-Alcoholic Wine

Non-Alcoholic Cocktails

Baby & Kids' Food

Baby & Kids' Health

Baby & Kids' Snacks

Diapering

Moms & Maternity

Our Diapers & Wipes

Healthy Homeschool Snacks for Every Craving

7 Quick, Easy, Fun, and Healthy Recipes to Cook With Your Kids

Synthetic Dye/Color Additive-Free

Fragrance-Free

Phthalate-Free

Health Concerns

Herbs & Homeopathy

Protein & Fitness

Dishwashing

Home Fragrance

Household Cleaners

Kitchen Supplies

Laundry

Paper Products

Storage & Organization

BPA-Free (Not Intentionally Added)

Essential Oils

Paraben-Free

Cat Food & Treats

Dog Food & Treats

Pet Care

Best Sellers

How to Prep for a New Dog or Cat

10 Nontoxic Pet-Friendly Cleaning Products

Grain-Free

Soy-Free

Exclusives

Clearance

Gift Guide

Gift Cards

Gift Boxes

Gifts